The cup just got crunchy. Each cup features a smooth, super peanut-buttery Butterfinger filling with just the right amount of crunchy pieces mixed in, all surrounded by delicious real milk chocolate.
- Each cup features a smooth, super peanut-buttery Butterfinger filling with just the right amount of crunchy pieces mixed in, all surrounded by delicious real milk chocolate
- The cup just got crunchy
- Perfect for peanut butter lovers
- Kosher Dairy
- 230 Calories per pack
- Certified kosher
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
If I could give them a 6 star review, I would!!!, April 7, 2014
By Contagioncat
These are awesome. If you love Reese's PB cups and Butterfinger candy bars, then this little cup is paradise. It is like Reese's and Butterfinger got married!!!! Oh yeah....
They're Alright, April 1, 2014
By Tom
I found these while shopping at Target. I've never seen these before, so I thought it would be nice to try. The texture of the filling is really nice, but the taste is not very inspiring. They were nice to try, but I prefer Reese's.
Love Butterfingers, Something not right with Butterfinger cups, April 1, 2014
By David L. Ayersman "deck farmer" (Colfax, Ca. USA)
Butterfingers are one of my all-time favorite candy bars, so I had very high expectations when I found these at the store. I opened the pack and shared one of the "cups" with a friend who said Butterfingers might be her favorite candy bar. We were both very disappointed. There was a strange bitter flavor and not much Butterfinger flavor. I almost threw half of my piece away. If I want Butterfinger flavor, I will get a Butterfinger bar.
Very delightful and a nice addition to the peanut butter cup market......., March 29, 2014
By x16kuunt
Very delightful and a nice addition to the peanut butter cup market. Who knew that butterfinger pieces and peanut butter would go together so right. This my favorite way I like enjoying butterfingers.
BEST CANDY EVER!!!!!, March 29, 2014
By R. Childs (Carthage, TX)
I found these when my son and I were on a road trip over spring break. The girl at the convenience store suggested that I buy more than just one package because they couldn't keep them on the shelves, and they aren't sold everywhere. She told me that she had even purchased an entire case for herself. Well, I thought she was pretty much insane. When we we finally reached our destination, I tried one of the cups and instantly fell in love. I couldn't find more anywhere we went during our trip. On our way back home, we stopped at the same convenience store to buy all they had, but someone else had beaten us to the punch. He and I were so disappointed! Then I realized that Amazon would surely have them. They did, and they're less expensive than buying them in a convenience store. It is very rare that I eat candy, but I just ordered my second case of them this morning. They are even better when kept in the refrigerator.
Nice change from Reese's, March 21, 2014
By lmttom
The difference is the peanut butter is very smooth with speckles of Butterfinger crunch within. Surprisingly delicious and for me, better than Butterfinger themselves due to the thicker coating of chocolate embracement. Their unique squarish, sleek low profile, gives a unique twist to original Reese's, yet smarter design as less damaging potential foreseen. If you enjoy Butterfinger then I can't see how not being impressed by texture, flavor, and modern shape these tasty treats confirm. Funny to say, the peanut butter has a reddish-orangish tint to it, maintaining the retro patented candy bar of layered orange crunch stored within. Enjoy!
PB Cups Butterfinger, March 20, 2014
By J. Melton
These are good, but not what I was expecting, more like your average buttercup and less like the Butterfinger that I was expecting. Tasty though if you aren't expecting Butterfinger...
Smooth chocolate, tons of peanut butter and a hint of crunch, March 20, 2014
By Akash (Washington, DC)
I was shocked by how much I liked these. I even prefer them to Reese's Peanut Butter cups at this point. The peanut butter is smoother, the chocolate is better and I love the layer of crunch they've added. Don't get me wrong, they're terrible for you and the serving size is a bit too large but they are delicious.
Knocked my favorite candy off the podium, March 19, 2014
By Sprout (Port Townsend, WA)
I've been a big Reese's Peanut Butter Cups fan my entire life. I also like Butterfingers, so I was excited to try this. Rather surprisingly, it greatly exceeded my expectations and is now a definite favorite. It still has the smoothness of the PB Cups, the right amount of sweetness, a hint of saltiness, and a nice mellow crunch that makes it just that much more enjoyable to eat. I strongly recommend giving these a try.
Classic Taste Brilliantly Delivered, February 27, 2014
By John Werner VINE VOICE
O.K., my heading may be a bit heavy on the drama...As if I'm the Butterfinger marketing department's head of press releases! LOL! Well, this is an event and if you already like Butterfinger candy bars your mouth will confirm this the first Butterfinger Peanut Butter Cup you treat it to!
I always liked that candied taste of the Butterfinger bar, but confess I was more of a Reese's person since the peanut butter and chocolate was by far the main attraction and with the Reese's Cups you didn't have shards of candied peanut butter in your lap. Still, the occasional Butterfinger was a requisite special treat.
Someone at Butterfinger is brilliant. No, I'm serious. That candied peanut butter taste is really special and they've come up with the perfect delivery platform for the rest of us who steer toward Reese's Cups. This is every bit as good as Reeses, to me at least, which is huge. Just as good yet totally different while sharing some of the same specialness only chocolate and peanut butter can claim. The creamy candied center here is the star and the milk chocolate cup is the absolute perfect delivery vehicle as well as synergistic accompaniment pushing it higher. In fact, after reading my review I do stand by my subject line: This stuff is brilliant and I've got to get some right now!
Nice peanut butter cups, February 22, 2014
By Nick Alec VINE VOICE
I love Reeses peanut butter cups so i was looking forward to trying out the Butterfinger version. I think overall its a well done conversion. It's definitely a crunchier cup experience that Reeses. Unlike the Butterfinger bars, their cup version doesnt cause chunks of it to get stuck in your molars. I'd personally stick with Reese because it think the chocolate tastes better, but these are also a nice option in the cup market.
